Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Gray cedar-shingle house with a white entry portico, blue door, granite steps and autumn planting beside a brick walk.

Gillis Family Tavern on Plymouth's Main Street: What Moved

November 5, 2026

Rick Vayo went to dinner at Gillis Family Tavern twice before he told anyone who he was. On one of those visits he brought about ten people, which he called a stress test for the kitchen and the servers. "We had everything from pizza to salmon," he told the Plymouth Independent. "I think someone had a steak, someone else had a salad." Everything came out on time. Then the developer, who owns the former Proof 22 storefront downtown, went back to the Gillis family and said, "Let's talk about what we can do here."

That meal is the real start of the tavern's new chapter at 22 Main Street, where Gillis Family Tavern was open by mid-October, according to the Patriot Ledger. Construction pushed the family out of the Jenney Grist Mill. What brought them to Main Street was a landlord with a specific idea of what downtown was missing, and a tenant he had already watched handle a full table.

Why the Mill Stopped Working for Lunch

Gillis Family Tavern opened at the historic Jenney Grist Mill in March 2023, according to the tavern's own site. In 2024 the town began a $20.9 million project to remake the Jenney Pond area, and the restaurant ended up on the edge of an active work zone. The Independent described heavy equipment, a contractor trailer and stacked materials taking up free parking around the pond. It also described police officers directing traffic in and out of the Spring Lane lot on weekdays.

The hit landed on one meal more than the others. "We lost at least $2,000 a day on lunch," Jimmy Gillis told the Independent. Dinner held up better because the crews had packed up by evening, and regulars kept making their way through the site. Visitors, the paper reported, tended to take one look and eat somewhere else. "On nights and weekends, we did pretty well," Gillis said, "but not enough to carry the lunch money we were losing."

He told the paper he had hoped for some financial help from the town or the federal government. That didn't happen. The project is partly funded by a $10 million National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration grant. Town Manager Derek Brindisi called the work "extremely complicated." He listed its parts as upgrading the Jenney Pond dam, improving the stormwater system, building a fish bypass and repairing the walkway to Brewster Gardens. In the same email to the Independent, he said the town's Department of Energy and Environment "has been working closely with area businesses to limit any negative impact."

After about a year and a half of that, the tavern closed at the end of May. The timeline also explains why the family didn't wait it out. When the Independent reported the closure in July, completion of the Jenney Pond work had already slipped to spring of next year. The original plan to avoid the summer tourist season had been dropped. A business that depends on lunch can't spend another full season behind a fence and hope the dinner crowd covers it.

What the Landlord Was Looking For

The Main Street side of the story starts with an empty storefront. Proof 22 had operated at 22 Main Street until August 2025. That month the Independent reported that its owners would not reopen and had given up the liquor license. Vayo, whose company Megryco owns the space, told the paper the relationship "fizzled out." He said he wanted the next tenant to be "what we want to see for downtown."

He was clear about what that meant.

"My view has always been that downtown Plymouth needs an eclectic mix of dining options. We need three more Cork + Tables, no question about that. But we're also lacking a little bit in what I would term the mid-tier, or American cuisine. It can't all be 'fine dining.'"

Vayo said this in the same Plymouth Independent interview, and added that the Gillises were "putting a lot of money into it." A table of ten ordering everything from pizza to salmon showed him whether one kitchen could cover the middle price tier he thought downtown lacked.

The Gillis family's plans matched his. Jimmy Gillis described the new place to the Independent as an accessible "bistro pub." "You can have your pizza, your wings, salads, but you can also have a real good chicken or steak dinner," he said. "I don't want to say high end, but better than mid-range." He was just as direct about the room. "We took everything down to the walls," he said, and later: "We're still a family restaurant."

The Room at 22 Main Street

The Patriot Ledger reported that the space was fully renovated and that the tavern was back to pouring Guinness and serving pub food like wings, pizza and sandwiches. Before opening, Gillis described what he was building to the Independent.

  • Exposed brick and a copper ceiling
  • Antique chandeliers and wall sconces
  • Cherry wood floors and what he called "unbelievably comfortable seats"
  • Big-screen TVs, though "we're not going to overdo it"
  • Reasonable prices

The menu on the tavern's OpenTable page, marked as updated October 15, 2026, covers the same range as Vayo's test dinner. It includes crab cakes, prime-rib spring rolls, nachos, wings, steak frites, fish and chips, steak tips, salmon and swordfish. One practical note: parts of that page still show the old 6 Spring Lane address, so use the Main Street address for directions.

For the hours, the tavern's website lists the following.

Day Open Kitchen closes
Monday to Saturday 11 a.m. to midnight 10 p.m.
Sunday 10 a.m. to midnight 10 p.m.

The phone number is 774-773-3041.

The 11 a.m. opening on weekdays connects back to the reason for the move. Lunch was the meal the mill location lost. On Main Street, the tavern opens its doors at lunchtime on a block people can walk to without crossing a construction site. In the summer, Gillis had told the Independent he hoped to have the TVs showing NFL games by September, and that October might be more realistic given the paperwork involved in opening a restaurant. The tavern was open by mid-October, so it hit the later of his two targets. The Sunday 10 a.m. start suggests Gillis means football Sundays seriously.

The Empty Space by the Brook

The tavern left a space behind on Spring Lane, and its future has not been announced. In November 2023, the Independent reported that the Plimoth Grist Mill property was for sale and that the town was among the possible buyers. At that point the town had not yet applied for Community Preservation Act funds. The fall 2025 and spring 2026 Town Meeting warrants carried no article to acquire the property. The fall 2025 warrant proposed $900,000 for a trail on town-owned land at Jenney Pond and Town Brook, and the spring 2026 warrant changed how the Jenney Pond restoration would be paid for. No new tenant has been announced for the former Gillis space.

The town's own plans show what is coming to the area around the building. In December 2024 the Select Board saw plans for a Jenney Grist Mill Plaza, alongside the dam repairs and a nature-like fishway bypass. The Independent reported that the broader work includes a bypass behind the mill, an accessible Town Brook trail and a replacement wheelchair-accessible footbridge. When it's done, the mill will sit on a rebuilt, more walkable stretch of Town Brook. In July the Independent put completion at spring of next year, which means spring 2027.

So the Gillis family left the mill just before the setting around it is due to improve. Whoever moves into the mill next will open beside a finished pond and plaza. The family that lived through the construction did their rebuilding on Main Street, in a gutted room, for a landlord who picked them after a dinner for ten. "We'll be ready," Jimmy Gillis told the Independent in July. "We're Irish stubborn." As of the Patriot Ledger's October report, the tavern was open at 22 Main Street.

When a familiar downtown storefront changes hands, it shifts how a block feels day to day, and I watch those changes closely because the people I work with ask about them. If you're curious how changes on Main Street and around Jenney Pond affect the homes nearby, I'm glad to talk it through. Jennifer Churchill is here when you'd like to connect.

Follow Me On Instagram