In 1892, Frederick Law Olmsted's fee for redesigning Bates Park, at the corner of Allerton and Vernon streets, came to $11.91. The whole project cost $100, and that paid for the labor, settees, trees, shrubs, seed and three cornerstones too. This fall Plymouth is spending about $600,000 on the Training Green, the largest of the three parks Olmsted's office designed for the town, according to the Plymouth Independent.
Inflation explains only a small part of that gap. In a 2023 column for the Independent, Plymouth architect Bill Fornaciari put the $11.91 fee at about $400 in 2023 dollars. Most of the rest of the gap pays for work the 1890 plan never asked of a green that has been public ground since 1711. The town now wants it to meet accessibility standards, stay green through August, and light its war memorial after dark. The chain-link fence along Sandwich Street went up for that work. Burton Park and Bates Park, Olmsted's other two Plymouth parks, are still open in the meantime and are not part of this project.
What the Fence Is Holding In
The Training Green covers 1.4 acres between Pleasant Street, Sandwich Street, and North and South Green streets, just south of the downtown business district. It has been public ground since 1711. Militia and later military units drilled there until World War II, and it is still where Plymouth's Memorial Day and Veterans Day parades traditionally end.
The Independent's October 9 report lists the work:
- Replacing and regrading the cracked, uneven walkways
- Repairing and resetting the stairs, and adding railings
- Adding paths that meet the Americans with Disabilities Act
- Putting in an underground irrigation system for a lawn that often browns out at the peak of summer tourist season
- Lighting the flagpole and the Civil War monument at the center of the green
Crews have also been protecting the roots of the park's trees from the stress of excavation. Nick Faiella, the town's parks and forestry superintendent, told the Independent the goal is to finish most of the work before winter. He described the priorities like this:
"Overall, it's about safety and accessibility, but we are going to respect its history. It's one of the oldest parks still being used in the country."
The Independent noted that neighborhood dogs have lost a favorite walking route while the fence is up. If yours is one of them, the alternatives are below.
An 1890 Plan, With Modern Wiring
The Olmsted Archives hold Training Green drawings dated 1889 and 1890, and the Plymouth Park Commission built the 1890 version. In 1892 the commissioners decided the green should be "kept as an ornamental park, thereby increasing the beauty of the locality and the comfort of the neighborhood." The playground that had shared the ground moved to the Nathaniel Morton Grammar School. Fornaciari reads that change as a polite way of making the green a solemn place and a war memorial, and it has stayed that way.
The current project is trying to update that solemn, ornamental park without changing its character, and the hardest arguments have been over where to stop. At the October 2025 Town Meeting, the Community Preservation Committee recommended $644,000 for the restoration. The Visitors Service Board had already set aside $100,000. Town Meeting voted 74 to 66 to remove $220,000 for irrigation and lighting, then approved $424,000 for the restoration by 104 to 3, with one abstention, as the Independent reported. Speakers who backed the cut said the park did not need sprinklers. Town Manager Derek Brindisi said residents often ask for lighting in town parks and that the town has few places that honor its service members.
A year later, the project as the Independent describes it includes irrigation and lighting for the flagpole and monument. Lighting along the pedestrian paths is still out. According to that report, one argument against funding the path lighting was that Olmsted's plan had no lamps. Brindisi pointed to archival photos from Fast Eddie's barbershop, across Sandwich Street, that show gas lanterns around the edge of the park.
The monument is the part most likely to change how the green looks at night. Peter Blessington designed it, it was built in 1867, and it carries the names of 72 Plymouth men who died in the Civil War. About 5,000 people attended its dedication in 1869. "The monument should have been lit a long time ago," Faiella told the Independent.
The Two Olmsted Parks That Are Still Open
Having Olmsted designs for three parks puts Plymouth in unusual company for a town its size. His firm's other work includes Central Park in New York and the grounds of the U.S. Capitol. Plymouth Recreation lists both of the smaller parks as open.
Burton Park, 25 Whiting Street. The town lists it at 1.1 acres, and the Independent describes it as not far from the Training Green. It is made of two parcels. One is a rise once called Jumping Hill, in front of the Mount Pleasant School. The other is a narrow strip at the base of the hill that Nathaniel Morton gave to the town. Olmsted's plan filled in the base, planted the hill with barberry, juniper, and clumps of pitch pine and white pine, and set a row of elms along Whiting Street. His fee was $14.66. Fornaciari wrote that in the late 1960s this was his father's favorite place to watch fireworks launched from Stephens Field.
Bates Park, Allerton and Vernon streets. At 0.75 acres it is the smallest of the three. It started as Waverly Square, land Moses Bates gave the town in 1856. Olmsted's redesign was approved in 1892, and the park was rededicated in Bates's name.
If you want a longer Olmsted walk while the green is closed, the Court Street area has a few more connections:
- The Training Green's edge on Sandwich Street. The fence keeps you on the sidewalk, but you can still see the monument and how the paths are laid out.
- Burton Park on Whiting Street, to compare Jumping Hill with the plan's pines and junipers.
- Bates Park at Allerton and Vernon, a $100 park that has lasted more than 130 years.
- Olmsted Terrace, the street between Court Street and Standish Avenue. Frederick Law Olmsted Jr. gave the town the land for it. By 1940 he owned the Court Street home where his sister Marion had lived.
Fornaciari also notes a local story that the land bounded by Court, Hall, Standish and Olmsted belonged to the Olmsted family, and that a few specimen plantings from a family nursery still stand there. He presents it as something he has been told, not a confirmed record. After Olmsted retired in 1895, the firm became Olmsted Brothers under his sons. In Plymouth it did work on the Hornblower estate, now home to Plimoth Patuxet Museums, and made studies for the Knapp estate on that same Court Street land. If you want to see the original drawings, the Olmsted Archives albums are where Fornaciari suggests starting.
When the Fence Comes Down
Faiella's stated goal is to finish most of the work before winter. When the fence does come down, the visible changes will be smooth, level walkways, railings at the stairs, accessible paths into the center, and the 1867 monument and flagpole lit after dark. The paths themselves will stay unlit. Next summer will be the first real test of the irrigation, since the lawn usually browns out in the busy tourist months.
Brindisi told the Independent that even without path lighting the project will be a major upgrade, physically and symbolically, and called the green "a park that's been neglected for a long time." Burton Park and Bates Park, designed for fees of $14.66 and $11.91, stay open on Whiting Street and at Allerton and Vernon while the work continues.
The historic streets around these parks are some of Plymouth's most distinctive places to live. If a walk past Bates Park or along Olmsted Terrace has you curious about a house nearby, or about what a home near one of these greens is worth today, Jennifer Churchill is glad to talk it through. Let's Connect.